Translate

Sunday, 18 May 2025

Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test and Abstract Thinking

 Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test and Abstract Thinking



Most people, especially the educators are familiar with Piaget's final stage of cognitive development i.e. the Formal Operational Stage. According to Piaget, the stages of cognitive development come to a close with the attainment of this stage which consists in being capable of the 16 binary operations of propositional logic such as that of Russel and Whitehead. 

Atomic propositions are combined into molecular propositions in terms of conjunction distinction and negation and when all combinatory possibilities are considered exhaustively by the child and hence is able to identify logical contradictions in his arguments, he is said to be formal operational. The onset age for the Genevan children he studied was around 12 to 13. 

When several years ago I investigated the same among secondary school children in Malaysia I found that a large percentage of  children even  around the ages of 16 or so were not  Formal Operational yet. Furthermore I also noticed that Abstract Thinking as such is DIFFERENT from formal operational thinking and is more INCLUSIVE.  I found that it is children who are abstract thinkers who are good learners and a large percentage of them end up in the institutions of higher learning.

Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test helped me considerably in the systematic investigation of such abstract thinking. Here it is necessary to distinguish TWO stages.
 

1. Early adolescence say children around the ages 13 to 15.

2. Late adolescence say children around the ages 15 to 18 or so.


The presence of the capacity for abstract thinking among the early adolescence is shown by Baums of the following description:


Pillar-like trunk opening up at both ends and absolutely clean  i.e. without any strokes or shading inside and outside. There is globular envelope covering completely the open ended top of the trunk. Inside the crown are ball-like fruits just globular with stick-like stems but just hanging in the air.

For the late adolescence it is somewhat different and more differentiated. We have the same clean trunk opening up at the bottom but at the top now we have radiating branches each ending with its own cloud-like envelopes.

These Baums were found to occur  mostly in A and B; very rarely in C and D.

I have named them 'KalaivaaNith tharu' Baums indicating the presence of the Goddess of learning, KalaivaaNi or Saraswathi.  The whiteness and clarity is common to both; KalaivaaNi is always seen to wear WHITE  garments, sit on WHITE  lotus  and the vehicle is annappaRavai, also Pure White in colour.

I noticed  the following intellectual capacities among such children no matter boys or girls:

1. Normally such children are described by teachers as 'BRIGHT"( notice the mataphor here) and QUICK to understand whatever presented in the class.

2. There is penetrative GAZE and along with it a PERCEPTUAL ACUMEN which I think is the central cognitive factor in abstract thinking. They listen attentively , digest quite fast whatever presented and extract the ESSENCE from it all and lodge them in their memory all in good speed so that they can FOLLOW the teacher and provide the correct answers when demanded of them by the teacher.

3. They may not spend much time pouring over books but spend considerable amount of time on THINKING about the lessons which they may do even while playing.

4. Not only they learn in a systematic and organised way but also are self-disciplined and well behaved. They have more control over their emotions than  an average child  of their age group.

5. On the whole they are inclined in the direction of science and mathematics and when streaming  into the arts and sciences begins , as it does in Malaysia around the age 16 or so, they tend to be put in the science stream though a small number also end up in the arts.

It appears to be that the essence of abstract thinking consists in being able to establish a psychic fissure between self and the sensory stimulations that one gets bombarded with always. It is this  fissure that enables them to SEE objectively whatever that is presented in the class and EXTRACT the essence and throw away the non-essential. In this way they manage to put more information into their long term memory compared to children who are incapable of this and hence unable to RETAIN much of what is presented during instruction.

It appears to be me, on the basis of such studies, in order to make a student a successful learner we have to train his perceptual acumen, the way he SEES things. The development of intelligence belongs to the phenomenology of perception, of making the child SEE with a penetrating GAZE. 

This has a very interesting implication for educational technology that I shall not venture into at the moment.


Ullaganar.

Former lecturer of University Science Malaysia.


Editing by Ari Marappan.

Friday, 16 May 2025

Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test and The Intelligence of Children.

Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test  and the Intelligence of Young Children




 

Dear Friends,

Lately there has been  very interesting comments by Mani M. Manivannan from the USA  and Dr Jeyabarathi of Sungai Petani on the inadequacies of the various kinds of psychometric testing of intelligence currently in use all over the world. Most of these are of questionnaire type which in opinion do not bring out contents of the unconscious due to its bias nature. I will write on that subject in another paper. 

Prompted by these observations I decided  to write a series of simple articles about using Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test ( LSBT ) as a way for 'measuring' human intelligence. There is no quantitative, statistical analysis here but only the identification of symbolic elements indicative of the presence of high analytical acumen . The theoretical framework for explaining all these hinges on the notions of Natham and Bindhu or Yin and Yang or Anima and Animus of Analytical Psychology and which is also rendered as the Moon and Sun principles in the alchemical traditions both in the East and West. What I mention are only the summaries of research reports written after extensive research done by Prof Kimio Yoshikawa and associates in Japan  and by myself in Malaysia.

Piagetian-like Stages of Development and Baum Test.

In the book "The Tree Drawing Test and Cross Cultural Psychology" written jointly by Prof. Kimio Yoshikawa and myself there is an  outline of the theory of intelligence through the study of the image forming cognitive processes of children in many countries all over the world. A general pattern indicative of cognitive functioning emerges through such studies. The test consisted asking the children" Draw a tree bearing fruits" which now in the Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test ( LSBT ) is only the first instruction for Baum A. However using thousands of such drawings of children all over the world Yoshikawa was able to draw a chart indicative of stages of cognitive development as follows.

The drawings were classified into :

1. Adult Forms.

2. Adolescent Forms.

3. infant Forms, and 

4. Infantoid Forms. 


The Adult Forms are the natural looking trees, drawings which allow us to identify the tree is quite clearly. The adolescent forms are quite close to that but look like a patch-up work with geometrical shapes put together. The infant forms are incomplete in a way with only indications of branches. The infantoid forms are more like scribbles consisting of lines and circles.

It was found that the onset age for adult forms is around   6 years and goes on till 9 or 10. It was also found the infantoid forms of children around the ages 3 to 4 are universal, quite the same all over the world. Working on this I postulated a psychic operation: that of assimilation in which a child who begins with his egocentric representation of a tree,  slowly modifies it to resemble the natural. This postulate was based on a longitudinal study  of a few children over a number of years. In further studies, conducted by some of my  students, this stage was also seen to correlate with Piaget's concrete operational stage.

Such children were also found to be better learners than others. They are less egocentric and because of that are able to UNDERSTAND better what is presented to them either at home or school.

Another study that I conducted with Prof. Shripathi Upadhyaya, from the medical school of University Science Malaysia,  USM  ( Penang ) disclosed that those children with IQ less than 100 and hence treated INCAPABLE of normal learning and hence treated as special children lacked a particular ability: if they draw the crown, they cannot draw the trunk; and if they draw the trunk then cannot draw the crown

It is this and the fact that the infantoid forms quite often assume the shape of circle sitting on a rectangular trunk that led me  to postulate the workings of Natham and Bindhu. It looks as though the JOINT workings of these principles are necessary for normal functioning, just to be  ordinary learners.

Another study undertaken along with the above children,  indicated that  the drawings of children with hearing impairment and speech impairment are overall statistically indistinguishable from those of children who are classified as slow learners in the primary schools. These children are normal in that they can hear and talk but in their brain functioning they are similar to the ones with hearing and speech impairment. Parts of their brain are not functioning at all and therefore they are not able to process cognitively ALL the information presented to them in the class. Special attention has to be paid to make them understand what the average child understands in a single presentation.

Now after the modification of standard Baum Test into Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test where there are now FOUR Baums to be drawn, I found the ability to draw the COCONUT TREE  has something to do with analytical thinking. Such children are normally said to be  quite intelligent by the teachers. Now coconut tree is, in its structure, is  very close to the SUN because from the top of the trunk, the branches radiate out like the rays of the SUN. This led me to think that it is the  strong presence of the SUN principle (Natham, Yang, Animus etc) that correlates with analytical intelligence and perhaps also something related to the LEFT hemspherical dominance in cognitive functioning.

Please DO NOT GENERALISE these to adolescents and adults. They have DIFFERENT ways of showing their intelligence and are much more complicated. The onset of sexuality changes the whole thing. But roughly we can say that only adolescents and young adults who can re-channel their sexual libido into the intellectual through the exercise of self control are good learners. This can be related with the notions Icca Sakthi ( Desires ), Kiriya Sakthi ( capacity for action) and Njana Sakthi ( capacity for intellectual accomplishments) and the observation that it is through the TRANSMUTATION of  Icca Sakthi into Njana Sakthi that a person  can be highly productive and creative.

More articles on such notions with concrete studies will be posted later.


Ullaganar.


Edited by Ari Marappan.

Wednesday, 14 May 2025

Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test and the symptom of diseases.

 Loganathan and Sivakumar's Baum Test ( LSBT ) and the symptoms of diseases. 



While there are many uncertainties and the matter stands to be investigated  further but there is enough confidence to make a claim. Furthermore this information in itself does no harm to any body, on the contrary it may be helpful, may even save lives.  Using the LSBT  I have  met with these symptoms already on several occasions, and  in one case at least, with considerable in -depth study.


The Symptom 1:

The ROOTS of any one of the trees drawn in the LSBT being crossed along with dark shadings.  The roots are below the ground but there are definite dark patches.

This is the common kind of features I met with among cancer patients and an SLE case. The SLE patients are those who have some problems in blood so that there is production of large quantities of blood proteins, and where the body  reacts against the persons own tissues. A pamphlet I obtained describes it as: The disease varies considerably from person to person with improvement or remission (total disappearance  of symptoms) occurring between periods of active disease. Occasionally, the disease can become a threat to life when the kidneys, brain or other vital organs are involved. later I found out that this is an autoimmune disease.

The patient was young lady 19 years of age and who was brought to me when the kidneys were already affected and her lips were terribly infected. The following morning the LSBT was given before she was taken to the hospital for intensive attention. All the Baums drawn were sickly looking, frail, broken etc but Baum B had the features as above: the roots crossed as if cut off with dark patches everywhere, only that it was not excessively as it was with cancer patients. While in cancer patients it is extensive, it was so with SLE cases such as the one I happened to study.

Suspecting that the disease may be psychical, something due to the psyche being attacked by GIGGOSUM, the Anava Malam of the Siddhas that in astrology is recognized as the SANI, I recommended a series of acts of psychic purification like going to the temple regularly etc etc. The medical attention and this kind activities of psychic purification resulted in fast recovery and the subject is now being treated with the allopathic medicines to arrest the further deterioration of the kidneys. At least the subject was brought up to this level, something that was not possible initially.


Sympton 2:


There are  symptoms that show themselves  in LSBT is spike-like or knive-like formations on the trunk. This is a sign that the subject is suffering from acute hypertension that may lead to severe heart attacks. One subject who was warned of this possibility  in fact died a few weeks later precisely in the manner indicated.

Some Theoretical Considerations

While I do not want to be over confident and claim for LSBT  what it cannot in fact offer, nevertheless I believe, and in this I have the whole of the Siddha Medical System behind me, that there are many diseases that the Siddhas called Kanma Noy that medicine, surgery and so forth cannot cure but only religious rituals that are directed at purifying the soul. When the soul is attacked by the GIGGOSUM, the Anava malam, death-bringing diseases both physical and psychical are suffered. No amount of medicine can cure such diseases for they do not reach the soul deep enough . This matter has been discussed extensively by Arunandi in his IrupaIrupathu. Furthermore the GIGGOSUM as observed by them is NOT the kind of stuff that allows to be dislodged from the psyche through pharmacological treatments.  The soul cannot be purified by medicines but only rituals of the religious type that are concerned with installing the divine archetypes in the soul again. It is the strong presence of positive archetypes in the soul that can dislodge the GIGGOSUM from the soul and save the person from death. The Siddha medical system emphasizes this aspect very strongly. The believe that there are limits to medical treatment and where they fail, religious rituals of the purification type is the alternative available for cure.

Whether you believe it or not , I leave it to you.  But I must mention that there is growing disenchantment with Western Medical System  even in America (correct me if I am wrong) and Siddha Medical System is being favored again at least for some kind of diseases. It may be possible that  this form of Medical System can benefit immensely by incorporating LSBT as an integral part of medical diagnosis.

I must also confess that what are available as SYMPTOMS are in fact metaphors of a kind : the person is communicating that his ROOTS are cut off meaning the sources of psychic nourishment are not anymore available to him. The GIGGOSUM by its very strong presence in that area where KUNDALINI is produced PREVENTS its flow into the body system making it defenceless against the attack of the viruses of various kind. The Siddhas mention that this happens when the GIGGOSUM is lodged inside the spinal cord that links the brain to the sexual organs. Religious rituals are unavoidable for dislodging the ANAVAM not only from the Spinal Cord but perhaps from anywhere inside  the soul. I invite the readers to think about these matters further with reference to comments the Siddhas have made about these matters.


Ullaganar


Edited by Ari Marappan.


Note by the editor : LSBT is not to be construed as a diagnosis tool in diagnosing medical conditions yet. In our research, which is still ongoing, it is showing some interesting findings and it may take years before we come to a more concrete conclusion. There are some research papers which see some correlation with psychological conditions such as schizophrenia, anxiety, depression and so on with Baums drawn. At best, for now, it can supplement other more established diagnosis methods. For any medical conditions please consult your healthcare professional.